The city of Tiburon, California (the
name mean ÒsharkÓ in Spanish) banned
them from all restaurants. The Chicago
City Council is trying to do the same in
Òthe city that works.Ó Health advocates
try to get them thrown off all elementary
and secondary school menus.
Are trans fats really that bad for you?
The short answer is, "Yes!" Partially hydrogenated
or hydrogenised oils are ubiquitous
in packaged and processed foods.
They give cake toppings their Òluscious
smoothness and moisture,Ó and let baked
goods stay on store shelves months and
years. From an epidemiologic standpoint,
they appear to clog arteries and increase
stroke and heart attack rates more than
saturated fats.
But it pays to know history. How did
we get to this state of affairs? Courtesy
of Pamela Hartman Cohen in the most
recent ÒHarvard Public Health Review,Ó
here is a brief history of trans fats:
Approximately 9,000 years ago:
Trans fats hit the human diet in a small
way. People start regularly eating milk
and dairy products produced by newly
domesticated goats, sheep and cows.
-
1903: The first industrial patent of
trans fats is granted. Over the next 100
years their use grows exponentially.
Processed with trans fats, foods are kept
palatable for years and are easily be transported.
With time, trans fat products like
Crisco become cheap. 
-
Mid-1950Õs:
University of
Minnesota epidemiologist
Ancel
Keys starts publishing
studies of varied European
populations
showing that saturated
fats cause
cardiovascular
disease, the leading
killer in America.
-
1985: Harvard Researcher Frank Sacks
points out that beef fat is used everywhere
to fry fast foods. As meat-based
saturated fats are now vilified, the outcry
provokes many fast food chains to shift
to trans fats.
-
1980ÕsÐ1998: The government-backed
program to move Americans to low fat
diets increases the backlash against red
meat and saturated fats. Plant-based trans
fats are used, especially in baked goods, to
fill in the gap.
-
1990: Researchers show that trans
fats decrease HDL (good) cholesterol,
while increasing LDL (bad) cholesterol
by major amounts.
-
1994: Walter Willett and others publish
reports that trans fats are more damaging
to the heart than saturated fats. Attempts
to regulate trans fats are put down by the
FDA. However, Unilever starts taking trans
fats out of its products.
-
2003: Frito Lay and other corporate
giants move away from trans fats.
-
2004: Evidence accumulates that trans
fats increase bodily inflammation. Studies
argue they cause immediate spasm and
dysregulation of arterial walls.
-
2005: The Department of
Agriculture creates a new series of
food pyramids. Specific recommendations
to avoid trans fats are left out.
ItÕs an old story. Something once regarded
as normal and good, namely red meat, is
demonized because of its saturated fat
content. ItÕs frequent replacement, trans
fats, turns out to be worse. As of this year,
the law is that American food manufacturers
must list trans fats on product labels.
Except they donÕt.
It may be the law, but itÕs another thing
to enforce it. Food labels rarely mentioned
the term Òtrans fats.Ó What you will
read on the box is Òpartially hydrogenised
soybean oil,Ó or, Òpartially hydrogenated
palm oil.Ó
Assuming you look at the labels. Most
people donÕt. If they did, they would realize
that many of their meals come from
oil barrels and are produced in industrial processes that look a lot more like petrochemical
cracking than anything normally
associated with food.
Trans fats were developed to make
foods cheaper, tastier, more appetizing,
long-lived. A hundred years ago probably
no one thought they would harm health.
We know they hurt survival now.
People often think that while cholesterol
and saturated fat laden steaks and hamburgers
may be Òbad,Ó crackers, cakes and
baked goods canÕt be as harmful. TheyÕre
wrong. Look for partially hydrogenised
or hydrogenated oils on the package and
you may find out part of the truth.
Ingesting a tiny bit of trans fats probably
wonÕt kill you. But eating a lot of
them will help kill tens of thousands of
Americans each year. DonÕt expect your
restaurant owners to change. Often they
donÕt know the nutritional effects of
many of the additives, preservatives and
sauces they use. You have to protect yourself. You can stick to whole foods, making
unprocessed plant foods the mainstay of your diet.
It also pays to read the labels. Food and drugs are much closer than people think. More than we want to know, we are what
we eat.
Dr. Matthew Edlund, M.D., M.O.H., director of The Center for Circadian Medicine, is an expert on applied public health, sleep medicine and psychiatry. A former professor at Brown and University of Texas medical schools, he can be reached via email to DocME@DoctorEdlund.com. And CLICK HERE to subscribe to our new Fitcast, via the iTunes Store.
|